How to Get Cast on Broadway: A Step-by-Step Guide for Aspiring Performers
Written by: Angelina Mullins Prattes
“There’s no one path to Broadway. At 18, I booked the world tour of Fosse, directed by the legendary Ann Reinking. My husband, Colt, graduated from the prestigious CCM Conservatory with a BFA in Musical Theatre and immediately booked the Broadway tour of High School Musical. Both worked. That’s what we always tell our students — the key is being honest enough with yourself to know where you're at in your journey and what your next right step is.”
If you're dreaming of being on a Broadway stage — whether you’re fresh out of a musical theatre program or have been grinding for years — you’re not alone. The path to getting cast on Broadway can feel overwhelming and uncertain — and rightfully so… you’ve been wanting this for your entire life.
As someone who’s both lived 22+ years as a Broadway performer and now coaches others to do the same, I’m here to say: it’s 100% possible. And while there’s no one formula, there are tried-and-true steps that consistently open doors.
Here’s how to get cast on Broadway — from someone who’s stood on those stages and helps others do the same every day.
🎓 1. Understand There’s No One Path — And That’s Okay
Let’s get this out of the way first.
Some performers go to prestigious BFA programs — like my husband, Colt, who graduated from CCM with a BFA in Musical Theatre. Others — like me — book major jobs as teenagers. I joined the Fosse world tour at 18. No degree. Just years of training, relentless hustle, and being in the right place at the right time.
Both paths are valid.
What matters more than how you start is that you’re consistent, coachable, and prepared when opportunity hits.
📍 2. Know Your Entry Points: Open Calls, Invites, and Replacements
There are three main ways performers get seen for Broadway:
Open Calls
Anyone can show up. These are posted on sites like Backstage and Playbill. Yes, it can mean you risk waiting all day (and if you're non-equity, maybe not getting seen that day) — but it’s a foot in the door.
Invited Appointments
These come through agents, casting relationships, or referrals. If you’re building a rep or networking actively, this becomes your main lane.
Replacements
Many Broadway actors book shows as replacements — mid-run, via agent submission or being known by the casting team.
👠 3. Train Like It’s Your Job — Because It Is
The key to being successful in this industry is to always be a student.
That mindset — staying curious, open, and in growth — is what keeps you competitive and connected. I train constantly, even now. The more I learn, the better I am for my own students.
If you’re serious about being on Broadway, you need to treat your body, voice, and acting skills like tools that need consistent sharpening. This means:
Taking classes that push you consistently (not just when you’re “feeling it”)
Working with coaches who have been on Broadway themselves — people who have walked the walk
Filming your work and learning how you read on camera
Stretching your range — yes, even the scary stuff (hello, tap or belting high Es)
That’s what we focus on at The Broadway Studio — helping performers bridge the gap between where they are and where Broadway needs them to be.
🎭 4. Curate a Killer Audition Book + Headshot Package
Your audition book, headshots, and resume are often your first impression.
Here’s what makes a difference:
Songs that let you actually tell a story — it’s not just about hitting the high notes
Headshots that look like you — casting wants to see YOU, not a styled version of someone you think they want
(We can recommend Broadway’s top photographers to you!)
🎯 Want help building your materials or refining your rep book?
Book a one-on-one or schedule a free consultation with The Broadway Studio here.
🤝 5. Get in the Room — and See Where You Stand
Getting into a Broadway audition room is a truly invaluable experience.
Wake up early and wait in that open call line. Experience what it feels like to stand in NYC at a real Broadway audition. You’ll walk away with:
A deeper understanding of how you stack up against other performers
Honest feedback from your own nerves and instincts
Insight into how casting responds to you
A clear view of the holes in your training
Save your pennies. Book the plane ticket!
Getting in the room is one of the most powerful tools for growth — whether you’re ready to book or just ready to learn.
❤️ Final Thoughts: Broadway Isn’t a Fantasy — It’s a Craft
I know it feels huge. Intimidating. Like some performers were born with a key you missed.
But I promise you — it’s not a fantasy. It’s a craft. And if you show up for it, train with intention, and trust the long game… doors open.
We’ve seen it again and again at The Broadway Studio. Students go from unsure to unstoppable — not because they’re perfect, but because they get prepared.
And the best part? You’re not doing it alone.
